Whatever is going on around her and whoever else is in the overripe Netflix murder mystery “His & Hers,” Marin Ireland is the one who gets it.
The latest project from the director of the feature film “Lady Macbeth” is straight-up trash. Ireland, who dresses down as fearlessly (“Dope Thief,” “Hell or High Water”) as any of her peers, is the foul-mouthed bug-eyed fury of this grisly “Mean Girls Grow up Meaner” series — nowhere near top-billed, but lowdown and “out there” in ways that more than do justice to the pulpy source material.
She doesn’t just play trashy, she revels in it.
Based on a novel by Alice Feeney and well-acted by a cast headed by Tessa Thompson, Jon Bernthal, Sunita Mani (“GLOW,” “Death of a Unicorn” and “The Roses”) and Pablo Schreiber, this is an infectious page-turner of a six-part series. Red herrings abound. “Oh no she/he DIDN’T” moments are tucked into laughably far-fetched plot twists and a sixth episode that so over-explains the last of those twists (clumsily given away earlier) that it waters down the impact of everything that came before.
Ireland sets it off every time her character, Zoe, appears. Thompson transforms into a TV anchor-beauty with cunning and “issues.” And Bernthal drawls through his turn as a north Georgia sheriff’s department detective whose true expertise isn’t really crime solving. His Jack Harper is a poster boy for Southern sheriff department policing, a man who like many of his peers truly expert in one thing — knowing just how much a compromised cop can get away with.
Thompson is a “leave of absence” Atlanta TV anchor who returns to her tony hometown of Dahlonega just in time to spy her not-ex-husband Jack cheating, with that cheating preceding the murder of his sex-in-a-truck-in-the-woods paramour. Ex-anchor Anna knows things, so many things that the “story” that erupts around her seems to be manipulated by her.
Her “There are at least two sides to every story” voice-over narration underscores this.
Jack’s enthusiastic sex partner (Jamie Tisdale) is a former private school classmate of Anna’s. Twenty years ago, Rachel was queen bee — the meanest and prettiest of the mean girls. She married money, settled into an “open marriage” and never had to give up her mean girl games.
As Det. Harper gasps at not just the murder of someone he was having a fling with, but a crime whose crime scene is covered with his DNA, he finds himself endlessly swatting away leads, queries and theories of the fresh-out-of-school partner Priya, (Mani) whom he nicknames “Boston.”
But is his not-quite-ex setting him up? The way she side-eyes him, smirks and ignores his many demands to “not report” this or that detail that she seems to know before him sets us up to believe that.
We know that in pulp fiction murder mysteries, it’s never the “obvious” first suspect we’re presented with, is it?
We meet the blonde anchor-woman (Rebecca Rittenhouse) who angled her way into the chair in Anna’s absence, and that bitter, cutthroat rivalry is renewed. Anchor-lady Lexy’s news videographer husband (Schreiber) is lured into that.
We hear of what sent Anna into her spiral and probably contributed to her husband losing an Atlanta PD job. We meet his boozy, broke, single-mom sister (Ireland) and Anna’s neglected, dementia-suffering mom (Crystal Fox).
And flashbacks take us back to St. Hilary’s School, where the rich girls and Anna mingled and Rachel’s corps included future school headmistress Helen Wang (Poppy Liu).
“His & Hers” is basically a slow-walked/series-length variation of “Out of Time,” the Carl Franklin-directed Denzel Washington/Eva Mendes thriller about a corrupt but not murderously dirty cop covering his tracks and his ass in a similar (enough) situation in South Florida, not North Georgia.
The sordid goings on, intimate connections and dirty secrets of a town where everybody knows everybody else make an inbred, over-the-top backdrop for a thriller that often shortchanges the stakes, the ticking clock element and “clues” that might come from the victim’s phone, the detective’s history, the reporter’s seeming manipulations and a junior detective who may at some point put a lot of pieces together.
Ireland, Chris Bauer as the less-than-grieving rich widowed husband and a few others take this script at its over-the-top face value. Bernthal is deliciously desperate and despicable as another unaccountable cop who assaults persons-of-interest and blurts accusations at others when where’s no one there to rein him in or correct his over-reaching lies.
The drawl grows more pronounced the more desperate Jack gets. Ireland gets her Cracker Dander Up. But most characters in this world would shed the accent — especially those in TV — and that’s the case here.
Thompson does a decent job of suggesting sinister and cunning in a character we’re ordered to misjudge and convict, based on the script.
Creator, writer and (in some episodes) director William Oldroyd works in “Twin Peaks” and “Chinatown” needle drops or overt references which underscore the lethal, blood-spattered playfulness he was going for.The lone “Southernism” in the dialogue also hints at the tone he was reaching for, a line uttered by a sheriff’s deputy to the detective.
She was “smilin’ like she got the last parkin’ spot at Cracker Barrel.”
But as a series, “His & Hers” is best at luring us in. The payoffs are consistently disappointing and the final episode basically an eye-roller, start-to-finish — all filler and “explanations” and “You didn’t see THAT coming” when we most certainly did and a long time before.
Rating: TV-MA, graphic bloody violence, explicit sex, profanity
Cast: Tessa Thompson, Jon Bernthal, Marin Ireland, Sunita Mani, Pablo Schreiber, Crystal Fox and Rebecca Rittenhouse
Credits: Created by William Oldroyd, based on a novel by Alice Feeney. A Netflix release.
Running time: Six episodes @ 40-47 minutes each